President Donald Trump will no longer pursue adding a question on citizenship to the 2020 US census questionnaire.
Instead, he
said he had directed officials to obtain the information through an executive
order for government agencies, as court challenges would have delayed a census.
"We will leave no stone
unturned," Trump said.
The retreat follows a
long fight over the inclusion of the question, which the Supreme Court had
blocked in June.
"We are not
backing down on our effort to determine the citizenship status of the United
States population," the US president said.
The order will require
government agencies to hand over documents regarding citizenship.
"As a result of
today's executive order we will be able to ensure the 2020 census generates an
accurate count of how many citizens, non-citizens and illegal aliens are in the
United States of America," Mr Trump said at the White House.
Kristen Clarke,
president of the National Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, told
the BBC she had concerns about Mr Trump's plans.
"This is
essentially an attempt to compile data on a mass scale in a way that is
unprecedented," she said. "We don't know how long it will take for
them to pull this data together, we don't know what they will do with that
data."
What reason did the Trump administration give?
The decision to
abandon the citizenship question was a "logistical impediment, not a legal
one", said Attorney General William Barr, standing alongside President
Trump.
He said
there was "ample justification" for the administration to include the
citizenship question.
But referring to court
injunctions, he said there was no way to "implement any new decision
without jeopardizing our ability to carry out the census".
Census questionnaires without
the citizenship question are already being printed.
Mr Barr repeatedly
congratulated Mr Trump on the executive order.
At the end of last month, the
Supreme Court returned the case to the Census Bureau in a 5-4 ruling that noted
the reason for including the question seemed "contrived".
Government lawyers indicated
they had dropped the question and officials began printing the 2020 census
without it.
But Mr Trump then announced
that he might consider an executive order to include the question or find other
ways to move forward.
Legal experts noted that an
executive order could not override a Supreme Court ruling.
In election
year, a question about citizenship on the 2020 census form would have been
hugely polarizing.
For Donald Trump, whose
stance on illegal immigration has defined his presidency, it would have been a
major success.
But it is not to be. The
hurdles proved too cumbersome and the administration acknowledged that
outstanding lawsuits could delay the completion of the census.
But never one to admit
defeat, Mr Trump framed his plan B as a "far more accurate" way to
count the non-citizen population. Officials, he said, would "leave no
stone unturned", in their quest to dig out citizenship information from existing
data held by government departments.
That could be seen as an
implied threat, but it means the census is likely to result in a more accurate
count, with those living in the US illegally less afraid to make their presence
known.
Census counts are used to
determine the allocation of seats in the House of Representatives and the
distribution of billions of dollars of funds in federal spending.
There had been concern that
impoverished areas would lose out if a significant number of residents chose
not to complete the form.
The citizenship
question has not appeared on a US census for all Americans since 1950, though
it has been put to some subsets of the population between 1970 and 2000.